Skip to content
Vouch

AthenaHQ alternatives: five AI visibility tools compared

AthenaHQ has a free plan and a $295 a month Starter plan sold in credits, with API access and extra credits as paid add-ons. Alternatives with published prices start at €29 for Otterly.AI and $39 for Vouch. Pick Vouch if you want to see where buyer conversations drop you.

Prices checked 15 November 2026.

Last updated by Vouch

Single-prompt tracking compared with a ThreadSingle-prompt tracking records one answer: named or not. A Thread records six answers and shows the stage where the brand drops out and which rival is chosen.Single-prompt trackingBest electric cycles under 50,000?Your brand: NamedOne answerNamed or not. The conversationthat follows is never seen.A Vouch Thread1. DiscoveryNamed2. ShortlistNamed3. ObjectionNamed4. TrustDropped5. ValueNot named6. DecisionRival chosenSix answersWhere you drop out, and who replaced you.
Single-prompt tracking sees one answer. A Thread sees the whole conversation, so it shows where a brand drops out and who takes its place.
Example data
The Thread diagnosis for a Demo Cycles prompt: the brand survives Discovery, Shortlist and Objection and is dropped at Trust; a bar per stage shows where the 5 conversations ended, 3 of them at Trust; the killer question is stage 4, Trust, “Is their after-sales service reliable?”; Rival Bikes was named instead and rivalbikes.example was the source cited; the recommendation is to publish service centre locations and warranty terms on one page.
The diagnosis: the killer question, who replaced the brand, the sources the assistant cited and what to publish next. Example data from the built-in demo brand Demo Cycles, not a real customer.

Vouch wrote this page, and Vouch is one of the alternatives, so read it with that in mind. Every fact about each tool comes from its own website. Last verified 15 Nov 2026; the sources are at the foot of the page, and anything a vendor does not publish is marked as such.

Why people look for an alternative to AthenaHQ

AthenaHQ's pricing page lists three plans. Essential is free, with 300 credits plus $25 of free credit and five models. Starter is $295 a month with 3,600 credits a month (one-month rollover), eleven models, unlimited topics, prompts and competitors, and CSV export. Enterprise is custom. One credit is one AI response, so what you track and how often decides how far the credits go. API access and extra credits are "optional add-ons billed on top" of Starter, with pricing on request. A monthly or annual toggle shows 17% off, but the annual Starter price is not stated on the page.

None of that is a flaw. It does mean you cannot work out a full monthly cost from the pricing page alone, which is why teams often compare other tools. See also Vouch vs AthenaHQ.

What to check before you switch

  1. How is usage counted? Credits, prompts, models, countries and projects are counted differently in every tool. Ask for a worked example at your prompt count.
  2. Which engines are on your plan? AthenaHQ's free plan lists five models and Starter eleven. Other tools cap active models or sell some as add-ons.
  3. What is an add-on and what is included? API access and extra credits are add-ons at AthenaHQ.
  4. What do you need to export? AthenaHQ lists CSV on Starter and BI tools on Enterprise.
  5. What happens after the first answer? Most tools report on single answers; ask what each does when the buyer asks about downsides, trust and price.

The alternatives at a glance

Vouch Profound Peec AI Otterly.AI Scrunch
Assistants tracked 7 on every plan (see methodology) 3 on trial; up to 10 on Enterprise 3 chosen from 8 on Starter to Advanced 7 named; prompts fall as you add engines 7 listed
Engines included at entry price 7 of 7, no add-ons (see methodology) 3 engines on the free trial; up to 10 on Enterprise source 3 models; extra models cost $30 to $140 a month source 4 of 7 engines on Lite; every engine uses credits source 7 listed on every plan source
Entry price $39 a month Free trial; Enterprise custom $95 a month €29 a month $300 a month, or $250 billed annually
Buyer-conversation view Yes: six-stage Threads on 4 of the 7 assistants Not stated Not stated Not stated Not stated
Alerts No Not stated Not stated Yes Stated on home page
Exports PDF report with a live dashboard link on every paid plan; no CSV; read-only REST API and MCP on Pro and Agency CSV and JSON on Enterprise CSV on every plan Reports and export on every plan Data API on Enterprise

Vouch

Vouch follows the conversation a buyer has with an AI assistant. A Thread asks six questions in order, Discovery, Shortlist, Objection, Trust, Value and Decision, and records the stage where your brand stops being named and which brands replace it. It tracks ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode and Copilot on every plan, with no add-ons. Starter is $39 a month for 15 tracked prompts; every plan is on the Vouch pricing page. Vouch has no alerts or CSV export today. It has a read-only REST API and an MCP server on Pro and Agency.

Best for: teams that want to know which follow-up question costs them the recommendation.

Profound

Profound is built for enterprise teams. The pricing page lists a free trial and a custom-priced Enterprise plan with up to ten engines, CSV and JSON exports, an API and SSO. See Profound pricing for what is and is not published.

Best for: large teams that want breadth and governance under one contract.

Peec AI

Peec AI tracks visibility, position and sentiment for your prompts and lists CSV exports on every plan, an API from Pro and a Data Studio connector from Advanced. Starter is $95 a month for 50 prompts on 3 models. See Peec AI pricing.

Best for: teams that report through spreadsheets, Looker Studio or an API.

Otterly.AI

Otterly.AI lists Lite at €29 a month, sells credits, and its home page describes alerts, a content audit and a public API. See Otterly.AI pricing for how credits turn into prompts.

Best for: teams that want low-cost tracking with alerts.

Scrunch

Scrunch tracks prompts, topics and entities, watches AI bot crawls, and its home page describes alerts and scheduled reports. Starter is $300 a month, or $250 billed annually, with 350 custom prompts, three user licences and a 7-day trial. See Scrunch AI alternatives.

Best for: teams that want monitoring and AI crawler data together.

How to choose

If credits are the issue, compare a flat prompt count: Peec AI and Vouch both state prompts per plan. If you need alerts, Otterly.AI and Scrunch describe them. If you need enterprise breadth, look at Profound. If your question is where in the buying conversation assistants stop recommending you, that is what Vouch measures; what happens after the first answer explains why. If you want content recommendations, a Shopify link and eleven models in one product, AthenaHQ remains a strong choice. For a free first look, try the AI readiness audit.

Vouch is invite-only for now. To see how Vouch asks each assistant and scores a conversation, read the methodology.

Sources: athenahq.ai, athenahq.ai, tryprofound.com, peec.ai, webflow.otterly.ai, webflow.otterly.ai, scrunch.com, scrunch.com.

Common questions

What is the best alternative to AthenaHQ?

It depends on what you need. Otterly.AI has the lowest published paid price at €29 a month, Peec AI lists CSV on every plan, Vouch's Starter is $39 a month with seven assistants, and Profound and Scrunch suit larger teams. Prices checked 15 Nov 2026.

Why do teams look for an AthenaHQ alternative?

Often the credit model. AthenaHQ's Starter is $295 a month with 3,600 credits, where one credit is one AI response, and API access and extra credits are paid add-ons priced on request. Teams that want a flat prompt count or a published add-on price compare other tools.

Is there a free AthenaHQ alternative?

Not among the tools here: AthenaHQ itself has the free plan, with $25 of credit and five models. Profound offers a 7-day free trial and Scrunch a 7-day trial on Starter. No paid plan here starts below Otterly.AI's €29 a month.

Which AthenaHQ alternative has alerts?

Otterly.AI's home page lists alerts when brand mentions change, and Scrunch's home page says it combines alerts and scheduled reports. AthenaHQ lists real-time brand mention alerts. Vouch has no alerts today, and we did not find them on Peec AI's or Profound's pages.

Should I stay with AthenaHQ?

If you want content recommendations, alerts, CSV export, a Shopify integration and eleven models in one product, AthenaHQ covers that. Switch if you want a published add-on price, a flat prompt count, or a buyer-conversation view that records where a brand drops out.

Read next